Three People Fall Ill from Eating Traditional Chinese Medicine
Three individuals in China were hospitalized after consuming cooked sheep placenta, which is traditionally believed to have health benefits. A woman named Zhang from Guangdong province experienced frequent fevers and significant weight loss, leading her to seek medical attention. She was diagnosed with brucellosis, a bacterial infection that can be transmitted from animals to humans. Zhang's sister and brother-in-law also fell ill with the same disease after eating the placenta.
In Chinese culture, the placenta is considered nutritious and is referred to as ziheche in Traditional Chinese Medicine. It is thought to boost the immune system and help with various health issues such as fatigue and infertility. However, this incident has sparked discussions online about whether such traditional beliefs should continue to be upheld, especially given the health risks involved.
Original article (china)
Real Value Analysis
The article does not provide any immediate actionable information for readers. It does not offer any specific steps or instructions on how to avoid similar health risks or what to do if one suspects they have contracted brucellosis. There are no tools or resources mentioned that could assist readers in making informed decisions.
In terms of educational depth, the article provides some basic information about brucellosis and its transmission, as well as the traditional beliefs surrounding the consumption of sheep placenta. However, it does not delve deeply into the scientific or medical aspects of the disease or its treatment. It also fails to explore the historical or cultural significance of consuming placenta in Chinese culture, which could have added more depth to the understanding of this practice.
The personal relevance of this article is quite high, especially for those who follow traditional Chinese medicine practices or are interested in alternative health remedies. It highlights the potential risks associated with certain beliefs and practices, which could impact an individual's health and well-being. For those unfamiliar with these traditions, it may also spark curiosity and encourage further exploration of cultural practices and their potential effects.
While the article does not explicitly provide a public service function, it indirectly raises awareness about a health risk associated with a traditional practice. This could prompt readers to be more cautious and seek medical advice if they experience similar symptoms after consuming animal products. However, it does not offer any official warnings or emergency contacts, nor does it provide detailed safety advice beyond the basic information about brucellosis.
The practicality of the advice is limited as the article does not offer any specific guidance on how to prevent or manage brucellosis. It merely states the potential risks associated with consuming sheep placenta, but does not provide clear, actionable steps for readers to take if they wish to continue practicing traditional medicine while minimizing health risks.
In terms of long-term impact, the article does not offer any lasting solutions or strategies. It merely highlights a health risk and its potential consequences, without providing any long-term plans or suggestions for managing or preventing such incidents.
The emotional or psychological impact of the article is somewhat mixed. On one hand, it may cause readers to feel concerned or even fearful about the potential health risks associated with certain traditional practices. On the other hand, it could also prompt readers to be more critical and cautious, encouraging them to seek medical advice and make informed decisions about their health.
The article does not appear to be clickbait or driven by advertising. It presents a factual account of an incident and its potential health implications, without using sensational language or making exaggerated claims.
To improve its value, the article could have included more practical advice for readers. For example, it could have provided a list of symptoms associated with brucellosis and advised readers on when to seek medical attention. It could also have offered suggestions for safer alternatives to consuming sheep placenta, or directed readers to trusted sources for more information on traditional Chinese medicine practices and their potential risks.
In summary, the article provides some basic information about a health risk associated with a traditional practice, but fails to offer actionable steps, in-depth learning, or practical advice that readers can use to improve their health or make informed decisions. It raises awareness but does not provide the tools or guidance needed for readers to take meaningful action or make lasting changes.
Bias analysis
"A woman named Zhang from Guangdong province experienced frequent fevers and significant weight loss, leading her to seek medical attention."
This sentence uses passive voice to describe Zhang's symptoms and her decision to seek help. By using passive voice, it downplays Zhang's agency and makes it seem like these events happened to her without her active involvement. This bias shifts focus away from Zhang's personal experience and choices. It also implies that seeking medical attention was a natural response, rather than a conscious decision.
Emotion Resonance Analysis
The text conveys a range of emotions, primarily centered around concern and caution. The narrative begins with a sense of curiosity and intrigue as it introduces the traditional Chinese belief in the health benefits of consuming cooked sheep placenta. This initial curiosity, however, quickly shifts to concern and worry as the story unfolds, detailing the hospitalization of three individuals and their diagnosis with brucellosis, a bacterial infection.
The emotions of fear and caution are evident as the text highlights the potential health risks associated with this traditional practice. The use of words like "hospitalized," "frequent fevers," and "significant weight loss" paints a picture of serious illness, evoking a strong emotional response in readers. This emotional appeal is further emphasized by the personal story of Zhang, a woman who experienced these health issues firsthand, adding a layer of sympathy and empathy to the narrative.
The writer's choice of words and storytelling technique effectively builds a narrative that guides the reader's reaction. By presenting a personal story, the writer humanizes the issue, making it more relatable and impactful. The use of descriptive language, such as "significant weight loss," creates a vivid image in the reader's mind, heightening the emotional response.
Additionally, the writer employs a persuasive technique by presenting a contrast between traditional beliefs and the potential health risks. This contrast creates a sense of tension and uncertainty, encouraging readers to question the validity of these traditional practices. The repetition of the word "same" when describing the disease experienced by all three individuals emphasizes the seriousness and uniformity of the health issue, further driving home the potential dangers.
In summary, the text skillfully employs emotional language and storytelling to guide the reader's reaction, evoking concern, sympathy, and caution. By presenting a personal story and contrasting traditional beliefs with potential health risks, the writer effectively persuades readers to reconsider the safety and validity of certain practices, ultimately shaping public opinion and potentially influencing behavior.

