Ethical Innovations: Embracing Ethics in Technology

Ethical Innovations: Embracing Ethics in Technology

Menu

Coastal Erosion Threatens Lancelin's Homes and Tourism

In Lancelin, Western Australia, residents are expressing deep concern over severe coastal erosion threatening their town. Over the past year, more than 25 meters of land have been lost along the coastline, with reports indicating that over 10 meters vanished just since May. This situation has put homes and essential infrastructure at risk.

Local business owner Glen Trebilcock, who runs the Lancelin Sands Hotel, has initiated a petition for immediate government intervention. He emphasizes that without urgent action, both the safety of the foreshore and vital coastal structures could be compromised. The petition has garnered support from over 900 community members and was submitted to the Western Australian Legislative Council.

The Shire of Gingin's President, Linda Balcombe, has reached out to state officials for assistance but reports that there has been no response yet. She highlighted that their small local government lacks the resources needed to manage this crisis effectively.

The ongoing erosion is also impacting tourism in Lancelin; previously active tour groups have ceased visiting due to safety concerns related to the coastline's instability. In response to these challenges, a popular lookout near Trebilcock’s hotel is set for demolition next week due to safety issues.

While the Western Australian Government acknowledges awareness of these problems and is exploring options for assistance, locals continue to call for immediate support as they face an uncertain future amid this environmental challenge.

Original article

Real Value Analysis

This article does not provide actionable information in the sense that it does not offer specific steps or a clear plan of action for the readers to take. While it mentions a petition initiated by a local business owner, it does not provide details on how readers can get involved or contribute to this initiative.

Educational depth is lacking as well. While it presents facts about the coastal erosion and its impact on the town, it does not delve into the causes or potential solutions. There is no explanation of the underlying environmental factors or potential long-term effects, which limits the reader's understanding of the issue.

In terms of personal relevance, the article does highlight the direct impact on residents and businesses in Lancelin, which is a positive aspect. It shows how the erosion affects their safety, infrastructure, and tourism, which are all relevant to their daily lives and future plans.

However, the article does not serve a public service function in the traditional sense. While it raises awareness about the issue and the community's concerns, it does not provide official warnings, emergency contacts, or practical tools for readers to use. It mainly serves to inform and highlight the community's call for action.

The advice and steps mentioned, such as the petition and reaching out to state officials, are not very practical for the average reader. These actions are more suited to community leaders and those with specific roles in the local government or business sector. The article does not offer advice that the average resident can easily implement.

In terms of long-term impact, the article does not provide any lasting solutions or strategies. It mainly focuses on the current situation and the community's immediate concerns, leaving readers without a clear sense of how they can contribute to a sustainable and long-lasting resolution.

Emotionally, the article may evoke feelings of concern and a sense of urgency, but it does not offer any positive or empowering messages or strategies to help readers cope with these emotions. It primarily presents a problem without providing a clear path forward, which may leave readers feeling helpless or frustrated.

Finally, while the article does not contain explicit clickbait or sensationalized language, it does use dramatic words and a sense of urgency to highlight the severity of the situation. However, it does not overstate the issue or promise solutions it cannot deliver.

In summary, the article provides some value in raising awareness about the coastal erosion issue and its impact on the community. It highlights the personal relevance of the topic and the community's call for action. However, it lacks actionable steps, educational depth, practical advice, and a sense of long-term resolution, which limits its overall usefulness for the average reader.

Social Critique

It is evident that the severe coastal erosion in Lancelin poses a grave threat to the very fabric of this community, testing the moral bonds that hold families and neighbors together. The loss of land, which has now reached alarming proportions, endangers not only the physical structures but also the safety and well-being of the residents, including the most vulnerable: children and elders.

The actions of local business owner Glen Trebilcock, in initiating a petition for government intervention, demonstrate a sense of responsibility and a desire to protect the community. He understands that without swift action, the foreshore and vital coastal structures may be compromised, putting lives at risk. This is a man who recognizes his duty to his kin and neighbors, and his efforts to rally support reflect a strong sense of community spirit.

However, the lack of response from state officials, as reported by Shire of Gingin's President Linda Balcombe, is a cause for concern. It breaks the trust that should exist between the community and those who are meant to protect and support them. The small local government's plea for assistance is a plea for help in fulfilling their duty to their people, a duty that is now being neglected.

The impact of erosion on tourism is a further blow, as it not only affects the local economy but also the very essence of community life. Tour groups, once a vibrant part of Lancelin's social fabric, have now ceased visiting due to safety concerns. This isolation and the potential loss of income further weaken the community's ability to care for its resources and protect its future.

The planned demolition of the popular lookout near Trebilcock's hotel is a stark reminder of the community's vulnerability and the urgent need for action. It is a symbol of the erosion of not just the coastline but also of the community's sense of security and stability.

If this idea of neglect and inaction spreads, it will further erode the trust and responsibility within the community. Families will be divided, with some choosing to abandon their homes and land, while others may stay, trapped in a cycle of fear and uncertainty. The protection of children and elders, a sacred duty, will be compromised, and the survival of the people and their land will hang in the balance.

The consequences of such a spread of inaction are dire. It will lead to the fragmentation of communities, the breakdown of kinship bonds, and the loss of the very essence of what makes a community strong and resilient. The land, a sacred trust, will be further degraded, and the balance of life, so carefully maintained by our ancestors, will be disrupted.

To restore trust and duty, those who have neglected their responsibilities must acknowledge their error and take immediate action. They must work alongside the community, listening to their concerns and needs, and together, they must find solutions that protect and preserve the land and its people. Only then can the broken bonds be mended, and the community can once again stand strong, united in their shared duty to protect life and the land they call home.

Bias analysis

"The Shire of Gingin's President, Linda Balcombe, has reached out to state officials for assistance but reports that there has been no response yet."

This sentence uses passive voice to hide who is responsible for the lack of action. It suggests that the officials are not responding, but it does not explicitly state who is at fault. The use of passive voice shifts the focus away from the officials and their inaction. By saying "there has been no response," it avoids directly blaming the state officials, creating a sense of ambiguity. This bias helps the officials by downplaying their lack of involvement and shifts attention away from their potential negligence.

Emotion Resonance Analysis

The text evokes a range of emotions, primarily centered around concern, anxiety, and a sense of urgency. These emotions are expressed through the use of powerful language and descriptive phrases, which serve to highlight the severity of the situation and the impact it has on the community.

Concern is evident throughout the text, particularly in the opening paragraph, where the loss of over 25 meters of land along the coastline is described as a serious threat to homes and infrastructure. This concern is further emphasized by the actions of local business owner Glen Trebilcock, who initiates a petition for government intervention, highlighting the potential compromise of safety. The concern is shared by the community, with over 900 members supporting the petition, indicating a collective worry about the future of their town.

Anxiety is another prominent emotion, especially in the statements made by Shire of Gingin's President, Linda Balcombe. Her lack of response from state officials and the acknowledgment of their small government's limited resources create a sense of unease and worry. This anxiety is heightened by the ongoing erosion's impact on tourism, with active tour groups ceasing visits due to safety concerns, further emphasizing the town's vulnerability.

The text also conveys a sense of urgency, particularly in the description of the erosion's rapid progression, with over 10 meters of land lost since May. The planned demolition of a popular lookout near Trebilcock's hotel due to safety issues adds to this sense of immediacy, suggesting that time is of the essence.

These emotions are skillfully employed to guide the reader's reaction, creating a sense of empathy and urgency. By expressing concern and anxiety, the text aims to evoke a sympathetic response from the reader, encouraging them to understand the gravity of the situation and the potential consequences for the community. The sense of urgency is designed to inspire action, whether it be support for the petition or a call for immediate government intervention.

The writer's use of emotional language and descriptive phrases adds to the impact of the message. For instance, describing the erosion as a "severe" threat and the loss of land as a "vanishing" act creates a sense of drama and urgency. The repetition of the word "safety" throughout the text, especially in relation to the foreshore and coastal structures, further emphasizes the potential risks and the need for immediate action.

Additionally, the personal story of Glen Trebilcock, a local business owner, adds a human element to the narrative, making the issue more relatable and tangible. By sharing his concerns and actions, the writer builds trust and encourages readers to see the situation through the eyes of those directly affected, thus increasing the emotional connection and potential for action.

In summary, the text skillfully employs a range of emotions to guide the reader's reaction, creating a sense of empathy, urgency, and a call to action. The use of emotional language, repetition, and personal stories adds depth and impact to the message, ensuring that the reader understands the severity of the coastal erosion and the need for immediate support and intervention.

Cookie settings
X
This site uses cookies to offer you a better browsing experience.
You can accept them all, or choose the kinds of cookies you are happy to allow.
Privacy settings
Choose which cookies you wish to allow while you browse this website. Please note that some cookies cannot be turned off, because without them the website would not function.
Essential
To prevent spam this site uses Google Recaptcha in its contact forms.

This site may also use cookies for ecommerce and payment systems which are essential for the website to function properly.
Google Services
This site uses cookies from Google to access data such as the pages you visit and your IP address. Google services on this website may include:

- Google Maps
Data Driven
This site may use cookies to record visitor behavior, monitor ad conversions, and create audiences, including from:

- Google Analytics
- Google Ads conversion tracking
- Facebook (Meta Pixel)