Ethical Innovations: Embracing Ethics in Technology

Ethical Innovations: Embracing Ethics in Technology

Menu

Boeing 787 Crash: Fuel Cutoff Sparks Investigation into Tragedy

An Air India Boeing 787 Dreamliner crashed shortly after taking off from Ahmedabad, India, on June 12, resulting in the tragic loss of 241 lives out of the 242 people on board. The aircraft was en route to London when it encountered a critical failure just seconds after takeoff.

Investigations led by India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) began immediately. The team included experts from various fields and representatives from the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB). Two black boxes, which are crucial for understanding flight incidents, were recovered from the crash site—one found on a rooftop and another among debris.

By June 24, both black boxes were transported to an AAIB lab in Delhi for data extraction. Initial findings revealed that shortly before the crash, both engines' fuel cutoff switches had been flipped to "cutoff," leading to a loss of fuel supply. A preliminary report indicated that there was no immediate fault identified with either Boeing or GE at this stage of the investigation.

Recording data showed one pilot questioning why fuel had been cut off while the other denied having done so. This exchange occurred just before they transmitted an emergency "Mayday" call moments prior to the crash. A final report is expected within a year as investigations continue into this devastating incident.

Original article

Real Value Analysis

This article about the Air India plane crash doesn't give you any specific things to do or steps to follow, so it's not very helpful in that way. It doesn't teach you anything new or explain things in a way that makes it easier to understand. The story is about something that happened far away, so it might not feel like it affects your daily life or the things you do. It doesn't give you any important information that you can use right now or that will help you in an emergency. It's more like a report that tells you what happened, but it doesn't really guide you or tell you what to do next. It also doesn't seem to be trying to help people; it's more like a news story that wants you to keep reading and doesn't offer any real solutions or useful tips. So, while it tells a sad story, it doesn't really give you anything that you can use to make your life better or safer.

Social Critique

In evaluating the Boeing 787 crash, it's essential to consider the impact on families, community trust, and the stewardship of the land. The tragic loss of 241 lives has undoubtedly caused immense grief and disruption to the families and communities affected. The investigation into the crash highlights a critical failure in communication and responsibility among the pilots, which led to a catastrophic event.

The fact that one pilot questioned why fuel had been cut off while the other denied having done so raises concerns about accountability and trust within the cockpit. This breakdown in communication and responsibility can be seen as a failure of personal duty, which is essential for ensuring the safety of passengers.

Furthermore, this incident underscores the importance of local accountability and personal responsibility in maintaining safety standards. The reliance on technology, such as black boxes, to investigate accidents can be seen as a shift away from personal responsibility towards impersonal authorities. While technology can provide valuable insights, it is crucial to recognize that human error and communication breakdowns can have devastating consequences.

In terms of community trust, this incident may erode confidence in air travel and raise questions about safety protocols. The investigation's findings will be crucial in restoring trust and ensuring that similar incidents do not occur in the future.

Regarding stewardship of the land, this incident does not have direct implications for environmental sustainability. However, it highlights the importance of responsible management of resources, including human resources, to prevent such tragedies.

The real consequences of such incidents spreading unchecked would be a decline in community trust, increased fear and anxiety among air travelers, and potential long-term effects on family cohesion due to loss of life. It is essential to emphasize personal responsibility and local accountability in preventing such incidents and restoring trust in air travel.

Ultimately, this tragedy serves as a reminder that survival depends on deeds and daily care, not merely identity or feelings. It is crucial to prioritize personal duty, communication, and responsibility to prevent similar incidents from occurring in the future. By doing so, we can work towards rebuilding community trust and ensuring the safety of all individuals involved in air travel.

Bias analysis

"The aircraft was en route to London when it encountered a critical failure just seconds after takeoff."

This sentence uses passive voice to describe the crash, hiding the agency and responsibility of the pilots and the airline. It focuses on the destination, London, which adds a sense of tragedy and loss, but does not mention the origin of the flight or the airline involved. The use of "critical failure" is a strong phrase that suggests an external factor, diverting attention from potential human error.

"Investigations led by India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) began immediately."

Here, the focus is on the official investigation, which gives an air of impartiality and expertise. By mentioning the AAIB first, it emphasizes the government's role and expertise, potentially downplaying the involvement of other entities like Boeing and GE. This sentence also implies that the investigation started promptly, which may not be the full story.

"A preliminary report indicated that there was no immediate fault identified with either Boeing or GE at this stage of the investigation."

This statement is a form of virtue signaling. It suggests that the investigation is thorough and unbiased, and that no blame is being placed prematurely. However, it does not address potential issues with the aircraft or its manufacturers, which could be seen as a way to protect their reputation.

"Recording data showed one pilot questioning why fuel had been cut off while the other denied having done so."

The use of "recording data" adds an air of objectivity and reliability to the information. It implies that the pilots' words are being accurately represented, but it does not provide the full context or tone of their exchange. This sentence also hints at a potential disagreement or confusion between the pilots, which could be seen as a way to shift blame.

"A final report is expected within a year as investigations continue into this devastating incident."

By using words like "devastating," the text emphasizes the severity of the crash and its impact. This emotional language may influence readers' perceptions and expectations of the investigation's outcome. The mention of a final report within a year sets a timeline, but it does not guarantee a comprehensive or conclusive result, potentially creating a false sense of certainty.

Emotion Resonance Analysis

The text primarily evokes a sense of profound sadness and grief, which is the most dominant emotion throughout. This emotion is evident from the very beginning, where the tragic loss of lives is described, setting the tone for the entire narrative. The use of phrases like "tragic loss" and "devastating incident" underscores the magnitude of the event and the deep sorrow associated with it.

As the story progresses, the reader is likely to feel a growing sense of worry and concern. The mention of a critical failure and the immediate launch of investigations by the AAIB and NTSB experts heightens this feeling. The reader might start to wonder about the causes and potential implications of such a catastrophic event, especially given the involvement of international experts.

The revelation about the fuel cutoff switches adds a layer of confusion and potential anger. The pilots' exchange, with one questioning the cutoff and the other denying responsibility, suggests a possible human error, which could evoke anger or frustration in the reader, especially if they perceive a lack of accountability or understanding of the situation.

The text also aims to build trust and transparency. By mentioning the recovery of both black boxes and the immediate transportation to an AAIB lab for data extraction, the writer assures the reader that a thorough investigation is underway. This transparency is further emphasized by the preliminary report's indication that no immediate fault was found with Boeing or GE, suggesting a fair and unbiased approach to the investigation.

To persuade the reader, the writer employs several emotional appeals. The use of words like "critical failure," "tragic loss," and "devastating incident" paints a dire picture, evoking a strong emotional response. The repetition of the word "crash" also serves to emphasize the severity of the event. Additionally, the personal story of the pilots' exchange adds a human element, making the incident more relatable and emotionally impactful.

By skillfully weaving these emotions and persuasive techniques throughout the text, the writer guides the reader's reaction, ensuring they feel the gravity of the situation, worry about the causes, and trust in the investigation process. This emotional journey is crucial in shaping public opinion and understanding of such tragic events.

Cookie settings
X
This site uses cookies to offer you a better browsing experience.
You can accept them all, or choose the kinds of cookies you are happy to allow.
Privacy settings
Choose which cookies you wish to allow while you browse this website. Please note that some cookies cannot be turned off, because without them the website would not function.
Essential
To prevent spam this site uses Google Recaptcha in its contact forms.

This site may also use cookies for ecommerce and payment systems which are essential for the website to function properly.
Google Services
This site uses cookies from Google to access data such as the pages you visit and your IP address. Google services on this website may include:

- Google Maps
Data Driven
This site may use cookies to record visitor behavior, monitor ad conversions, and create audiences, including from:

- Google Analytics
- Google Ads conversion tracking
- Facebook (Meta Pixel)