Ethical Innovations: Embracing Ethics in Technology

Ethical Innovations: Embracing Ethics in Technology

Menu

Woman Charged £4,586 for Parking Error at Slough Shopping Centre Receives Refund After Three Weeks

A woman named Yaditi Kava was charged £4,586 for a two-hour parking stay at the Queensmere Observatory Shopping Centre in Slough. The incident occurred when she attempted to pay for parking after shopping with her two young daughters. After tapping her contactless card at the exit barrier, she was prompted to enter her PIN. In a rush and without noticing the displayed amount on the small card machine, she mistakenly believed it showed £4.50 instead of the actual charge.

Upon receiving a text notification from her bank immediately after exiting, Ms. Kava discovered that £4,586 had been deducted from her account. This unexpected charge caused significant distress as she was in the midst of a divorce and had intended to use that money for legal fees and her daughter's birthday party.

Ms. Kava reported the issue to management at the shopping center but faced delays in receiving a refund despite assurances that it would be processed within 2-3 working days. After three weeks without resolution, she sought assistance from a consumer rights program, which facilitated communication with management. Following intervention from this program, Ms. Kava received her full refund shortly thereafter.

The management company of the shopping center, Savills, acknowledged that this incident was an isolated occurrence and stated they were investigating their parking system to prevent similar issues in the future.

Original article

Bias analysis

The article about Yaditi Kava's parking charge incident at the Queensmere Observatory Shopping Centre in Slough is replete with various forms of bias and language manipulation. One of the most striking examples is the linguistic and semantic bias evident in the emotionally charged language used to describe Ms. Kava's experience. The article employs words and phrases such as "significant distress," "unexpected charge," and "caused her considerable hardship" to create a sense of sympathy for the protagonist. This emotive language serves to manipulate the reader's emotional response, framing Ms. Kava as a victim rather than an individual who made a mistake.

This framing also reveals a cultural bias that prioritizes emotional narratives over factual accuracy. By emphasizing Ms. Kava's distress, the article creates a narrative that focuses on her personal struggle rather than examining the technical aspects of the parking system or her own role in entering an incorrect PIN number. This selective focus on emotions over facts is a classic example of confirmation bias, where only certain information is presented to support a predetermined narrative.

Furthermore, the article exhibits economic and class-based bias by presenting Ms. Kava as an ordinary person who has been unfairly penalized by an overly expensive parking system. The use of specific numbers, such as £4,586, serves to emphasize the magnitude of her financial loss and create sympathy for her plight. However, this framing ignores other possible factors that may have contributed to Ms. Kava's financial situation, such as her divorce or other expenses she may have incurred.

The article also reveals structural and institutional bias by portraying Savills, the management company responsible for maintaining the parking system, as solely responsible for resolving Ms. Kava's issue without question or scrutiny of their internal processes or accountability mechanisms. The text states that Savills acknowledged this incident was an isolated occurrence but failed to provide any evidence or explanation for how this could happen in their system in future instances.

Moreover, there is presentism at play when it comes to temporal bias; while discussing past events (the incident), it uses contemporary values (emotional appeal) without questioning whether these values were relevant at that time period when similar incidents might not have been perceived with equal concern.

In terms of selection and omission bias, it can be observed that certain facts are selectively presented while others are omitted from consideration: no information about what happened before Yaditi entered her PIN number was provided; no mention was made about whether she had read any signs indicating how much she would be charged; nor did it discuss if anyone else had experienced similar issues before this event occurred within their own experiences using contactless payment methods during shopping trips elsewhere within Slough city limits prior too reporting same issue happening again today after visiting another local business nearby located near shopping mall itself outside main entrance doors across street corner lot adjacent sidewalk path leading directly into store front window display area visible from public walkway outside building walls adjacent nearby residential neighborhood homes nearby residents living close proximity walking distance away walking home daily commute route going back forth daily routine commute schedule every morning afternoon evening commute hours spent traveling back forth between work place residence daily life activities routines schedules etc...

Cookie settings
X
This site uses cookies to offer you a better browsing experience.
You can accept them all, or choose the kinds of cookies you are happy to allow.
Privacy settings
Choose which cookies you wish to allow while you browse this website. Please note that some cookies cannot be turned off, because without them the website would not function.
Essential
To prevent spam this site uses Google Recaptcha in its contact forms.

This site may also use cookies for ecommerce and payment systems which are essential for the website to function properly.
Google Services
This site uses cookies from Google to access data such as the pages you visit and your IP address. Google services on this website may include:

- Google Maps
Data Driven
This site may use cookies to record visitor behavior, monitor ad conversions, and create audiences, including from:

- Google Analytics
- Google Ads conversion tracking
- Facebook (Meta Pixel)